Checklist for Non Profit Organization: The CFO’s Guide for Choosing a New Financial System
Choosing a new financial system is one of the most critical infrastructure decisions a nonprofit CFO can make. It’s not just about replacing outdated software—it’s about setting up your organization for transparency, accountability, and growth. This article serves as a comprehensive nonprofit organization checklist to guide you through the process of selecting a new financial system.
Whether you’re dealing with fragmented tools, chasing funder reports across spreadsheets, or struggling with limited visibility into your finances, a modern financial system can help. But not all systems are created equal. And nonprofits have specific needs—multi-entity management, grant tracking, compliance, and fund accounting—that not every vendor understands.
This checklist is designed to help nonprofit CFOs cut through the noise, stay strategic, and make a well-informed decision that supports their mission now and in the future.
1. Pre-Implementation Planning
Define Financial Goals and Objectives
Defining financial goals and objectives is a cornerstone of starting a nonprofit organization. This process involves determining your financial needs, creating a budget, and establishing a plan for achieving financial sustainability—all while ensuring alignment with your mission and vision statements.
To define your financial goals and objectives, follow these steps::
- Conduct a Needs Assessment: Identify the financial requirements essential for your nonprofit organization to operate effectively.
- Create a Budget: Outline projected income and expenses to provide a financial roadmap.
- Establish a Sustainability Plan: Develop strategies for fundraising and grant writing to ensure long-term financial health.
- Define Key Performance Indicators (KPIs): Set measurable goals to track financial progress.
- Regular Review and Revision: Periodically reassess your financial goals to ensure they remain aligned with your organization’s mission and vision.
By taking these steps, you can create a solid financial foundation that supports your nonprofit organization’s mission and long-term success.
2. Align the System with the Organizational Strategy and Mission Statement
Before comparing features or vendors, step back and consider your organization's mission and strategic goals over the next 3–5 years.
Are you:
- Scaling programs to new locations?
- Diversifying funding sources?
- Centralizing finance across multiple entities?
- Preparing for a merger?
- Strengthening audit readiness?
Your financial system must support—not hinder—these goals. If you’re growing internationally, you’ll need multi-currency capabilities. If you’re consolidating finance, the system must seamlessly manage multiple entities or locations. The clearer your strategy, the easier it is to define system requirements.
Key Questions:
- What does our finance function need to look like in 3 years?
- Are we expecting more compliance, audits, or reporting complexity?
- How much growth do we anticipate—budget size, programs, staff?
- Are we prepared to comply with evolving employment laws and regulations?
3. Get Board Members and Stakeholders Buy-In Early
CFOs often drive system selection, but finance doesn’t operate in a vacuum. In nonprofits, operations, development, program, and IT teams often rely on financial data. Include them early.
Early involvement can also be facilitated through a kickoff board meeting to establish rapport and discuss critical matters.
Stakeholder involvement improves:
- System adoption
- Workflow alignment
- Data accuracy
- Reporting consistency
Involving end users helps avoid surprises like “I can’t track program expenses the way I need to” or “development can’t tie donations to impact.” It also strengthens the case for investment when multiple departments benefit.
Checklist:
- Identify key users across departments
- Document their current pain points
- Hold a discovery session to gather cross-functional input
- Map out who needs access and how they’ll use the system
- Schedule the first board meeting to align stakeholders and set expectations
4. Prioritize True Nonprofit Organization Functionality
Many financial systems claim to serve nonprofits, but they’re often adapted from for-profit models. Look for features built with nonprofit realities in mind, such as:
- Fund accounting
- Grant and donor tracking
- Budgeting by project or program
- Multi-entity consolidation
- Compliance reporting
- Restricted vs. Unrestricted Funds
- Allocation of shared costs across programs
Ensure your system can handle essential compliance tasks, such as managing your employer identification number and other regulatory requirements.
Generic systems may require expensive customization to meet these needs—or force you into workarounds.
Red Flags:
- The vendor can’t clearly explain how the system handles restricted funds
- Fund or grant tracking is done through spreadsheets or add-ons
- Reporting feels like an afterthought
- The system does not support proper classification and management of independent contractors
5. Assessing Current Financial Systems
Evaluate Current Financial Processes
Evaluating your current financial processes is essential for ensuring your nonprofit organization operates efficiently and effectively. This involves a comprehensive assessment of your financial systems, including accounting software, budgeting processes, and financial reporting.
To evaluate your current financial processes, consider the following steps: :
- Review Financial Statements: Examine your balance sheet, income statement, and cash flow statement to understand your financial position.
- Assess Accounting Software: Determine if your current software meets your organization’s needs or if an upgrade is necessary.
- Evaluate Budgeting Processes: Ensure your budgeting process effectively allocates resources to support your programs and initiatives.
- Ensure Compliance: Review your financial reporting requirements to ensure compliance with regulatory standards.
- Identify Areas for Improvement: Pinpoint inefficiencies and develop a plan to implement necessary changes.
By thoroughly evaluating your financial processes, you can identify areas for improvement and ensure your nonprofit organization meets its reporting requirements and operates at peak efficiency.
6. Assess Reporting Requirements and Visibility Capabilities
One of the biggest drivers for switching financial systems is reporting. Nonprofits must answer to funders, boards, auditors, and regulatory bodies—often with slightly different versions of the same data. Your new system should offer robust reporting capabilities to meet the needs of your board of directors and other stakeholders.
Your new system should offer:
- Customizable dashboards for real-time insights
- Role-based reporting (finance, program, fundraising)
- Easy grant, fund, and program-level reporting
- Drill-down capabilities from high-level summaries to transaction details
- Exportable or scheduled reports
Avoid systems in which finance staff constantly export to Excel to generate custom views. That’s a sign that the system isn’t built for transparency.
Must-Haves:
- Real-time dashboards tailored by role
- Built-in compliance and audit reports
- Automation for recurring or monthly reports
- Detailed grant funding reports to track and manage grant allocations and expenditures
7. Evaluate Integration Capabilities
Your financial system is part of a bigger tech stack. It must connect smoothly with systems like:
- CRM or donor management software
- Payroll and HR systems
- Grant management platforms
- Time tracking and expense systems
- Procurement tools
Look for open APIs, pre-built integrations, or at least a clear integration roadmap. A siloed financial system creates duplicate data entry, reporting mismatches, and higher risk of errors.
Clearly defined job descriptions for staff managing these integrations can streamline the process and ensure accountability
Questions to Ask:
- What systems does finance need to integrate with today?
- Are there manual processes that could be automated through integration?
- How easy is it to connect the new system to our existing tech stack?
- Are there any legal requirements we need to consider to legally incorporate these integrations into our existing systems?
8. Understand User Experience and Accessibility
A powerful system that’s hard to use won’t deliver results. Nonprofits often have lean teams—your system should empower users, not frustrate them.
Key considerations:
- Is the interface intuitive?
- Can non-finance staff (e.g., program managers) run reports or enter data without heavy training?
- Is the system cloud-based, with secure remote access?
- Are mobile features available for approvals or time tracking?
Consider how the system integrates with social media platforms to enhance your online presence and engagement.
User experience can be the difference between a successful rollout and a failed one. Look for systems that offer short learning curves, clear workflows, and self-service reporting..
9. Plan for Scalability and Flexibility
You’re not just buying for today—you’re building for tomorrow. Your new system should grow with you. That includes:
- Adding new entities or locations
- Scaling transaction volume
- Supporting multiple currencies or languages
- Handling increased user counts or data complexity
Ensure your system can handle the complexities of maintaining your tax-exempt status as you grow.
Flexibility is especially critical in nonprofits, where funding and operations can shift quickly due to grants, emergencies, or partnerships.
Choose a system that won’t force you into a costly upgrade—or worse, a replacement—if your organization changes significantly.
10. Know What’s Under the Hood: Security, Compliance, and Controlss
Nonprofits handle sensitive data: donor info, payroll, payment details, and financials. Your system must protect that data while maintaining transparency. These features are essential for nonprofit organizations to maintain trust and transparency with their stakeholders.
Make sure the platform offers:
- Role-based permissions
- Audit trails and version history
- Segregation of duties
- SOC 1 and/or SOC 2 compliance
- Secure cloud infrastructure with regular backups
Also consider compliance with local tax requirements, applicable accounting standards for not-for-profit organizations, and other financial regulations relevant to your organization’s size and jurisdiction.
11. Governance and Board Management
Support Board Members and Board Meetings
Supporting your board members and ensuring effective board meetings are critical for the governance and decision-making processes of your nonprofit organization. Providing board members with the necessary resources and information enables them to make informed decisions that align with your organization’s mission.
To support your board members and board meetings, follow these steps:
- Develop a Comprehensive Board Manual: Outline your organization’s governance structure, policies, and procedures to provide a clear reference for board members.
- Provide Regular Financial Reports: Keep board members informed with up-to-date financial reports and progress updates.
- Ensure Access to Resources: Offer training and development opportunities to equip board members with the skills they need.
- Establish Effective Communication: Implement a clear communication plan to keep board members engaged and informed.
- Evaluate Board Meetings: Regularly assess the effectiveness of your board meetings and make improvements as needed.
By supporting your board members and optimizing board meetings, you can enhance the governance of your nonprofit organization and ensure that decisions are made in the best interest of your mission and goals.
12. Dig into Implementation and Support
Implementation is often where projects succeed or fail. Don’t just ask “how long will it take?” Ask how the implementation will be managed.
Get clarity on:
- Who leads the project on the vendor side?
- Will you have a dedicated implementation manager?
- Is there nonprofit-specific onboarding?
- What training is included (and what costs extra)?
- What support is available post-launch?
Ensure that key roles, such as the Vice President of Finance, are involved in the implementation process.
Also, talk to references. Ask how smooth their implementation was and what they wish they’d done differently.
13. Total Cost of Ownership: Budget for the Whole Picturele
Sticker price is only part of the cost. Total cost of ownership includes:
- Licensing or subscription fees
- Implementation services
- Customization or add-ons
- Training and onboarding
- Ongoing support or upgrades
- Third-party integrations
Ensure that the total cost of ownership aligns with your mission statement and long-term financial goals.
Nonprofits often underestimate internal costs, such as staff time, process changes, and data cleanup. To avoid this, build in buffer time and resources.
A cheaper system that requires endless workarounds may cost more in the long run than one that costs more upfront but meets your needs out of the box.
14. Don’t Forget Change Management
New systems mean change, and change means disruption. Make sure your team is ready, informed, and supported. That includes:
- Clear communication about why the change is happening
- Training plans by role
- Internal champions or “super users”
- Feedback loops during rollout
- Time for learning and adjustment
Consider reaching out to other nonprofits to learn from their change management experiences.
The system is only as good as its users. Equip your team for success.
Final Thoughts
Choosing a new financial system is a major decision for any nonprofit organization. It requires time, thought, and alignment across teams. But when done right, it sets your organization up for greater transparency, better stewardship, and more impact. This nonprofit organization checklist will guide you through each step, ensuring a well-informed decision-making process.
Use this checklist to guide the process—from big-picture strategy to practical evaluation. Focus on what matters most: empowering your finance team, improving visibility, and enabling your mission.
Would you like further insights on how nonprofits can optimize financial reporting, strengthen operations, and improve donor management? Let’s start a conversation about how smarter financial solutions can help your organization achieve lasting impact.
Ready to strengthen your organization's resilience? Explore the Sage Intacct solution to learn more.
